Papa John's Delivery

Address: Our apartment! (Fresh from 1111 Fulton Street)
Purchase: One large cheese pizza
Cost: $15.99 (with tax, delivery, and $3 tip)
Pizza Rating:


So a Papa John's just opened down street from us, and last night seemed as good as any to try it out (in the name of blogging research, of course). While we do consider ourselves idealist, "keep it local" folks, the convenience of online ordering, 20 minute delivery, and deliciously buttery garlic sauce, we have to indulge in the Papa once in awhile. The two and half stars were pretty much awarded entirely upon those three qualities, (the garlic sauce winning 2 whole pizza-stars (YUM!), and the convenience bringing it up a 1/2). The pizza itself was a little cold, the sauce a little sweet, and the cheese a tad bit chunky (rather then the melted warm gooeyness you get from a truly artisnal slice). I was inclined to bump it up to a 3 after enjoying a hits-the-spot slice this morning from the fridge, but AJ refused to stoop so low.